Episode 8 — Love Them Harder
Musical Poetry with Asabaal is an audio blog series exploring the intersections of faith, identity, theology, and lived experience through music and spoken word. Each entry pairs a featured piece with reflection and commentary.
Opening Reflection
Growing up in church, the worship leader I viewed as a mentor of sorts made it a point to question how "Christian" Christian music was, and whether it was theologically "correct". I carried this with me into my adulthood and now into my artistry as well. So when Cory Asbury released Reckless Love and it blew up in Christian spaces, I remember scoffing. Is God's love really reckless and never-ending? Of course its popularity made it impossible to ignore as a serious candidate for playing at church events when I had the opportunity to shape the worship set.
At the end of the day, I couldn't allow myself to make that big a deal of the lyrics whether or not I thought they were theologically accurate. Jesus himself is recorded as telling us to love our enemies and pray for those that persecute us (Matthew 5). And if we're supposed to love our enemies, maybe God's love really does have no end.
Featured Lyrics Excerpt
I still believe in the healing for the church
But if the darkness has hold of her
There's a lot more work to do
Title: Love Them Harder
Project: I Never Asked to Be Queer
Format: Musical Poetry / Spoken Word
Closing Reflection
I'm in the ministry of reconciliation. You don't have to understand it to know that's how I see my work. But I'll say this. This is what it looks like to love them harder after they cast you out.
It's always God's mission to love them harder.
Commentary
After I digitally transitioned (new name & feminine-presenting photos on social media), the very same mentor/worship leader that inspired my dedication to theological depth and accuracy in my artistry reached out to me. He thought it was love. He saw me as walking a sinful path in need of correction. I was willing to reconnect and converse with him, but we had tension because he wouldn't call me by my God-given name, as if the name given by my parents was somehow superior. And beyond that, he refused to even agree to simply not call me by a name or use pronouns to identify me in conversation. I thought this a reasonable request that if he really did love me, he would love me hard enough to find a way to engage in conversation with me, because if I really was theologically wrong, then his love would show up as willingness to work with me in a way I was willing to work with him.
That's what I call loving them "harder".
Granted, Marquis lived in Montana while I was living in Wisconsin. But I was attending a local church in Wisconsin when I socially transitioned (which I did at the same time I digitally transitioned, I mean they are pretty tied, it's just when it's digital you have to deal with everyone from your entire life you are still connected to, not just those who live nearby). This church is called The Ridge Community Church.
My spouse at the time was spiritually gifted. I trusted her words. I had a deal with God about this. So when she told me she got her "gut feeling" about this church, which meant she felt the spiritual urge, I knew. Ok. This is my new church home. So even though my transition came as a shock to them, I believed we could work something out. After all, God had led me here, or so I believed. And while they were not comfortable with me singing on their band anymore, they were willing to buy me coffee, talk with me, get to know me, discuss difficult theological topics, and explore ways of unifying.
The man I spoke the most with - Tyler. A young pastor thrusted into responsibilities he never asked for, especially after COVID hit. He was under a lot of pressure, and it showed. So when new leadership was brought in to help with the evolution of the church, I knew this might bring tension. And sure enough, it did.
It was time to make a change. I was ready to re-engage with the community inside the church. I hadn't been attending church - only talking with Tyler and other members on staff. I wanted to attend a small group. They were ok with that. I wouldn't go to a women's group, but a mixed gender group, and that was fine. It was the day of the first session. I received a phone call about 10 minutes before I had to leave. I was actually heading out the door early when I received the call. It was from Tyler. His leadership had specifically asked him to tell me not to discuss gender or other related topics at the small group. Obviously that was a non-starter for me.
So I stood up for myself, once again reassuring him I was not going to cause issues, but I obviously would not be able to avoid discussing gender or other related topics should it come up in conversation, a likely thing to happen at some point being the only publicly queer member attending that small group. The trigger though was when I said it was unfair, even unChristlike, to treat me this way, Tyler was obviously conflicted, and tensions were rising between us.
Then he snapped. He said I was no longer welcome at the Ridge. I said that God had called me here and the only way I was not coming was if I was being legally excluded. So he said if I showed up on the campus, they would call the police and forcibly remove me from the property. So there it was. I was just excommunicated. The love stopped.
I was loving them harder the whole way, but they hit a breaking point. That's depressing. I've struggled with depression on and off in my life. Life really can hit in uncomfortable ways. That's why I always respected tylerhateslife's work. He talked about mental health. And I loved the acoustic and gritty elements he brought to the game. And I've always believed it's loving to give shoutouts to people you respect for whatever it is you respect them for. This song sure hits different now that he's no longer with us.